8383 South 48th St, 85044. 45 prices, copied from Rustlers Rooste's own menu, last checked 2026-11-01. Overall it's 21% cheaper than the Phoenix median for the same dishes, #6 of 57 ranked Phoenix restaurants for value (see the ranking). Best-value steaks here: The Judge (-56%), Wrangler Bone-In Rib Eye (-45%), The Marshal (-39%). Cheapest steak by weight: The Judge, $1.92/oz.
Restaurants change prices. Check their menu before you go.
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $39.00 | -30% | Tenderfoot Filet 8 oz · $4.88/oz Choice tenderloin, Cajun style option; cowboy butter add-on available for $3 |
| $34.00 | -1% | The Deputy 8 oz · $4.25/oz |
| $38.00 | -27% | The Sheriff 12 oz · $3.17/oz |
| $42.00 | -39% | The Marshal 16 oz · $2.63/oz |
| $42.00 | -39% | The Marshall 16 oz · $2.63/oz |
| $46.00 | -56% | The Judge 24 oz · $1.92/oz |
| $48.00 | -45% | Wrangler Bone-In Rib Eye 20 oz · $2.40/oz Genuine Angus beef |
| $34.00 | — | Vaquero Certified USDA prime sirloin ("the Coulotte") with two cheese enchiladas |
| $36.00 | -31% | Rustler's Cut Top Sirloin Steak 10 oz · $3.60/oz Certified USDA grade prime |
| $42.00 | -29% | New York Strip 12 oz · $3.50/oz Genuine Angus beef; cowboy butter add-on available for $3 |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $24.00 | -26% | Grilled Salmon Topped with honey dill butter, with rice pilaf and corn on the cob |
| $24.00 | +14% | Jumbo Shrimp Fried or Sautéed Served with rice pilaf and corn on the cob |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $12.00 | -25% | Fried Onion Rings |
| $12.00 | -25% | Fried Mushrooms |
| $9.00 | -36% | Sweet Potato Fries |
| $12.00 | -14% | Jumbo Potato Skins |
| $12.00 | -14% | South Mountain Nachos |
| $18.00 | +29% | South Mountain Nachos with Brisket |
| $14.00 | -42% | Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail gluten free |
| $16.00 | -6% | Buffalo Wings |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $22.00 | -39% | Prime Rib Dip Prime rib on a french roll, au jus, horseradish and fries |
| $31.00 | -14% | B.B.Q. Pork Ribs (Half Slab) Smoked daily for 10 hours, low and slow |
| $36.00 | 0% | Brisket & Sausages 8 oz · $4.50/oz 8 oz. of brisket and two jalapeño & cheddar smoked sausages |
| $36.00 | 0% | Beef Ribs 4 premium ribs, limited availability |
| $36.00 | 0% | Brisket and Two Jalapeño & Cheddar Smoked Sausages 8 oz · $4.50/oz |
| $39.00 | +8% | B.B.Q. Pork Ribs (Full Slab) Smoked daily for 10 hours, low and slow |
| $26.00 | 0% | Country Fried Steak Homestyle mashed potatoes with sausage country gravy and corn on the cob |
| $18.00 | -5% | Plant-Based Impossible Burger Topped with roasted green chili and jalapeño jack cheese, served with fries and vegetarian-style chili |
| $22.00 | +16% | Big Burger 12 oz · $1.83/oz 12 oz. ground fresh with chipotle mayo, jalapeños, fries and onion rings; choice of jalapeño jack, American, or Swiss cheese |
| $21.00 | -28% | Rotisserie Chicken Rustler's Rooste famous BBQ sauce on the side |
| $22.00 | +38% | BBQ Brisket Sandwich Chopped brisket topped with jalapeño jack cheese, served with homemade fries |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $8.00 | -53% | Cheesy Jalapeño Bacon Macaroni |
| $6.00 | -60% | Homestyle Mashed Potatoes with Sausage Country Gravy |
| $6.00 | -60% | Jumbo Baked Potato With all the fixin's |
| $6.00 | -60% | Jumbo Baked Potato with All the Fixin's |
| $6.00 | -60% | Grilled Asparagus |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $15.00 | -6% | 9 Layer Chocolate Cake |
| $25.00 | +56% | Birthday Package 9 Layer Cake, Cowboy Hat & Bandana |
| $9.00 | -36% | Bread Pudding With vanilla sauce |
| $9.00 | -36% | Bread Pudding with Vanilla Sauce |
| $7.00 | -33% | Ice Cream Sundae |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $9.00 | -42% | Kids Cheeseburger |
| $8.00 | 0% | Kids Chicken Fingers |
| $8.00 | -33% | Kids Mac & Cheese |