2 E Jefferson St #150, 85004. 132 prices, copied from Arrogant Butcher's own menu, last checked 2026-11-01. Overall it's 3% cheaper than the Phoenix median for the same dishes, #17 of 57 ranked Phoenix restaurants for value (see the ranking). Best-value steaks here: Slow Roasted Prime Rib (-17%). Cheapest steak by weight: Slow Roasted Prime Rib, $3.58/oz.
Restaurants change prices. Check their menu before you go.
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $51.00 | +4% | Filet Mignon 7 oz · $7.29/oz Red Wine, Crispy Shallot. Includes choice of one side |
| $65.00 | -7% | Filet Mignon 10 oz · $6.50/oz Red Wine, Crispy Shallot. Includes choice of one side |
| $43.00 | -17% | Slow Roasted Prime Rib 12 oz · $3.58/oz Au Jus & Creamy Horseradish. Includes choice of one side |
| $68.00 | — | Slow Roasted Prime Rib (double cut) Au Jus & Creamy Horseradish. Includes choice of one side |
| $68.00 | — | Double Cut Slow Roasted Prime Rib au jus & creamy horseradish |
| $47.00 | — | New York Strip au Poivre Peppercorn Sauce | gluten-free. Includes choice of one side |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $22.00 | -4% | Fish & Chips Beer Battered Rock Fish, Coleslaw & Fries |
| $3.75 | -82% | Oysters |
| $16.00 | — | 1/2 Dozen Oysters Happy hour menu |
| $32.00 | -1% | Atlantic Salmon Fregula Risotto, Grilled Broccolini, Butternut Squash Gastrique |
| $36.00 | -35% | Pacific Sea Bass Roasted Artichoke, Green Bean, Slow Roasted Tomato, Green Olive, Lemon Caper Butter | gluten-free |
| $4.50 | -79% | White Shrimp |
| $12.00 | — | Shrimp Cocktail Happy hour menu |
| $18.50 | -12% | Crispy Shrimp Shishito Pepper, Spicy Aioli |
| $27.00 | +29% | White Shrimp Rigatoni Melted Tomato Butter, Spinach, Lemon, Caper, Parmesan Bread Crumbs |
| $18.50 | -20% | Tuna Tataki Crispy Rice Spicy Avocado Crema, Truffled Sweet Soy, Sesame Cashew Crunch, Asian Herbs |
| $28.00 | +22% | Tuna Poke Bowl Avocado, Pineapple & Cucumber Kimchi, Shaved Radish, Snap Pea, Sriracha Crema, Sesame Cashew Crunch |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $11.00 | — | Cheese Plate Happy hour menu Whipped Brie, Aged Cheddar, Goat Cheese, Apple, Date, Cranberry Pesto, Toasted Ciabatta |
| $29.00 | +38% | The Butcher's Platter Sliced Prosciutto, Bacon Wrapped Andouille Dates, Black Truffle Devile... |
| $11.50 | — | Spinach & Artichoke Dip Happy hour menu Sour Cream, Pico de Gallo, Warm Tortilla Chips |
| $12.00 | — | House Made Pretzels Happy hour menu Provolone Fondue |
| $14.50 | +4% | Simple Hummus Pickled Pepper Relish, Za'atar, Olive Oil, Lavash Crackers |
| $16.50 | +18% | Spinach & Artichoke Dip Sour Cream, Pico de Gallo, Warm Tortilla Chips | gluten-free |
| $17.50 | +25% | House Made Pretzels Provolone Fondue |
| $17.50 | +25% | House Soft Pretzels & Provolone Fondue |
| $9.00 | — | Crispy Brussels Sprouts Happy hour menu Red Chile Honey, Parmesan, Prosciutto Bread Crumb |
| $13.00 | -19% | Crispy Brussels Sprouts Red Chile Honey, Parmesan, Prosciutto Bread Crumb |
| $17.50 | +9% | Butcher's Meatballs Spicy Crushed Tomato, Ricotta Cheese, Garlic Bread |
| $17.50 | +9% | Butcher's Meatball spicy crushed tomato, ricotta cheese, garlic bread |
| $8.00 | — | Parmesan Truffle Fries Happy hour menu Truffle Aioli |
| $11.00 | — | Chicken Egg Rolls Happy hour menu Pineapple Sweet & Sour, Thai Basil, Cilantro |
| $14.00 | — | Smoked Carnitas Nachos Happy hour menu White Bean, Smashed Avocado, Sour Cream, Pico de Gallo, Jalapeño |
| $15.00 | +7% | Chicken Egg Rolls Pineapple Sweet & Sour, Thai Basil, Cilantro |
| $18.50 | +32% | Smoked Carnitas Nachos White Bean, Smashed Avocado, Sour Cream, Pico de Gallo, Jalapeño | gluten-free |
| $12.50 | -22% | Simple Salad Cucumber, Tomato, Parmesan, Champagne Vinaigrette | gluten-free |
| $16.00 | 0% | Ranch House Crispy Bacon, Avocado, Tomato, Red Onion, Blue Cheese, Buttermilk Dressing, Crouton |
| $16.50 | +3% | Green Goddess Caesar Brussels Sprout, Snap Pea, Avocado, Shishito Pepper, Romaine, Kale, Parmesan, Crouton |
| $10.00 | -23% | Daily Soup selection changes daily, call store for more details |
| $17.50 | +3% | Buffalo Chicken Wings Celery, Shaved Carrot, Parmesan, Ranch | gluten-free |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $25.00 | -4% | Butcher's Meatloaf Smashed Potato, Buttered Green Bean, Brown Sugar Tomato Glaze |
| $22.00 | +19% | Farmers Market Bowl Charred Avocado, Brussels Sprouts, Crispy Japanese Sweet Potato, Toasted Grains, Red Pepper Emulsion, Salted Cashew, Arugula, Chimichurri | vegan |
| $15.00 | — | AB Cheeseburger Happy hour menu White Cheddar, Grilled Onion, Shredded Lettuce, Pickle, Louie Sauce |
| $24.00 | +26% | AB Double Cheeseburger white cheddar, grilled onion, shredded lettuce, pickle, louie sauce |
| $26.00 | -10% | Shrimp, Chicken & Sausage Jambalaya Spicy Cajun Rice, Okra | gluten-free |
| $28.00 | -3% | Roasted Half Chicken Lemon Herb Butter | gluten-free. Includes choice of one side |
| $29.00 | 0% | Crispy Chicken Breast Jumbo Lump Crab, Green Bean, Lemon Caper Butter, Calabrian Chile |
| $30.00 | -32% | Prosciutto Wrapped Pork Truffled Potato Risotto, Brussels Sprouts, Toasted Pistachio, Cherry Gastrique, Herb Jus |
| $16.00 | -9% | Ranch House Salad crispy bacon, avocado, tomato, red onion, blue cheese, buttermilk dres... |
| $19.00 | +9% | Mediterranean Chopped Chicken Salad Heirloom Tomato, Artichoke, Golden Raisin, Cucumber, Cherry Pepper, Ol... |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $9.00 | +6% | Buttered Green Beans Snap Pea, Salted Almond | gluten-free |
| $9.00 | -14% | French Fries Truffle Aioli |
| $9.00 | -47% | Macaroni & Cheese Aged Cheddar, Provolone, Parmesan |
| $9.00 | -40% | Crispy Japanese Sweet Potato Hot Honey, Togarashi | gluten-free |
| $9.00 | -40% | Loaded Smashed Potato Bacon, White Cheddar, Scallion | gluten-free |
| $9.00 | -40% | Brussels Sprouts & Squash Maple Emulsion, House Herbs |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $12.00 | +20% | Warm Fudge Brownie Vanilla Gelato, Salted Caramel Sauce, Toasted Pecan | gluten-free, vegan |
| $12.00 | -25% | Sticky Caramel Cake Coffee Chantilly, Candied Walnut |
| $12.00 | -14% | Mascarpone Cheesecake Seasonal Fruit, Vanilla Crema, Pistachio Crumble |
| $20.00 | +11% | Royale Banana Split (pour deux) Neapolitan Ice Cream Trio, Caramelized Banana, Salted Caramel, Strawberry, Chocolate Fudge, Candied Marcona Almond, Luxardo Cherry | gluten-free |
| Price | vs Phoenix median | Item |
|---|---|---|
| $5.00 | — | Ska Brewing Hazy IPA Happy hour menu |
| $5.00 | — | Dos XX Lager Happy hour menu |
| $5.00 | — | Greenwood Brewing Light Lager Happy hour menu |
| $5.00 | — | Mother Road Tower Station IPA Happy hour menu |
| $5.00 | — | America Loves Cold Beer Blonde Happy hour menu |
| $5.00 | — | AZ Local Ale Beer Co. Cactus Bird Juicy Wheat Happy hour menu |
| $6.00 | -25% | Bud Light |
| $6.00 | -25% | Coors Light |
| $6.00 | -25% | Athletic Brewing Non-Alc Run Wild IPA | Upside Dawn Golden |
| $6.50 | -19% | Modelo Especial |
| $6.50 | -19% | Michelob Ultra |
| $6.50 | -19% | Four Peaks Bad Birdie Juicy Golden Ale |
| $6.50 | -19% | Huss Brewing Scottsdale Blonde |
| $6.50 | -19% | Dos XX Lager 16 oz · $0.41/oz |
| $6.50 | -19% | Greenwood Brewing Light Lager 16 oz · $0.41/oz |
| $6.50 | -19% | Dos XX Lager |
| $6.50 | -19% | Greenwood Brewing Light Lager |
| $7.00 | -12% | Stella Artois |
| $7.50 | -6% | America Loves Cold Beer Blonde 16 oz · $0.47/oz |
| $7.50 | -6% | AZ Loc Ale Beer Co. Cactus Bird Juicy Wheat 16 oz · $0.47/oz |
| $7.50 | -6% | AZ Loc Ale Beer Co. Cactus Bird Juicy Wheat |
| $7.50 | -6% | America Loves Cold Beer Blonde |
| $8.00 | 0% | Mother Road Tower Station IPA |
| $8.00 | 0% | Greenwood Brewing Light Lager 20 oz · $0.40/oz |
| $8.00 | 0% | Dos XX Lager 20 oz · $0.40/oz |
| $8.00 | 0% | Ska Brewing Hazy IPA 16 oz · $0.50/oz |
| $8.00 | 0% | Mother Road Tower Station IPA 16 oz · $0.50/oz |
| $8.00 | 0% | Coronado Brewing Crisp Cider |
| $8.00 | 0% | Guinness Draught 14.9 oz · $0.54/oz |
| $8.00 | 0% | Ska Brewing Hazy IPA |
| $9.00 | +13% | High Noon Assorted Flavors |
| $9.00 | +13% | America Loves Cold Beer Blonde 20 oz · $0.45/oz |
| $9.00 | +13% | AZ Loc Ale Beer Co. Cactus Bird Juicy Wheat 20 oz · $0.45/oz |
| $9.50 | +19% | Ska Brewing Hazy IPA 20 oz · $0.48/oz |
| $9.50 | +19% | Mother Road Tower Station IPA 20 oz · $0.48/oz |
| $9.00 | — | Daiquiri Happy hour menu Rum, Fresh Lime, Cane Sugar |
| $9.00 | — | Mule Happy hour menu Vodka, Ginger, Fresh Lime, Soda |
| $9.00 | — | Margarita Happy hour menu Blanco Tequila, Fresh Lime, Organic Agave |
| $9.00 | — | Old Fashioned Happy hour menu Bourbon, Luxy Cherry, Angostura, Orange Zest |
| $9.00 | -42% | Pink Dove Smashed Grapefruit, Toasted Cinnamon, Sea Salt, Chilled Seltzer |
| $9.00 | -42% | 1st Street Spritz Smashed Blackberry, Pomegranate, Fresh Lime, Sparkling Coconut Water |
| $14.00 | -10% | Seasonal Sangria Blackberry, Peach, E&J Brandy, Lime, Red Wine |
| $14.00 | -10% | Downtown Mule Smirnoff Vodka, Ginger Agave, Fresh Pressed Lime |
| $15.00 | -3% | Pineapple Gold Rush Tincup Bourbon, Heirloom Pineapple Amaro, Clover Honey, Pineapple Sour |
| $15.00 | -3% | Blood Orange Paloma Tradicional Tequila Blanco, Blood Orange, Fresh Lime, Fever Tree Grapefruit Soda |
| $15.00 | -3% | The Hurricane Club Cacao Jacked White Rum, Havana Club Añejo Blanco, Passion Fruit, Pineapple, Lemon |
| $16.00 | +3% | Fairway Margarita Tradicional Tequila Reposado, Fresh Lime, Organic Agave |
| $16.00 | +3% | Classic Old Fashioned Redemption Bourbon, Angostura, Orange Zest, Fancy Cherry |
| $16.00 | +3% | Blackberry Coconut Margarita Corazón Blanco, Orange Liqueur, Tart Lime |
| $16.00 | +3% | Strawberry Rhubarb Spritz Belvedere Organic Vodka, Fresh Strawberry, Rhubarb, Lemon, Sparkling Wine |
| $4.95 | -17% | Black Iced Tea |
| $4.95 | -17% | Green Iced Tea |
| $9.00 | +50% | Espresso-No-Tini Slow Drip Coffee, Mexican Cinnamon, Orange Oil, Cold Foam |
| $16.00 | +167% | Espressotini Espresso Infused Vodka, Slow-Steeped Cold Brew, Madagascar Vanilla |
| $64.00 | +967% | Espressotini Tree |
| $4.95 | -59% | Dr. Pepper |
| $7.00 | — | Well Spirits Happy hour menu |
| $4.95 | -29% | Lemonade |
| $4.95 | -29% | Coke |
| $4.95 | -29% | Diet Coke |
| $4.95 | -29% | Sprite |
| $5.00 | -29% | Acqua Panna |
| $5.00 | -29% | Pellegrino half liter |
| $9.00 | +29% | Garden Harvest Ripe Strawberry, Mint Leaf, Yuzu & Lime Fever Tree |
| $16.00 | 0% | Tamarindo Mezcalita Amarás Verde, Astral Blanco, Gran Malo, Hibiscus Tea Leaf, Tart Lime, Spiced Summer Salt |
| $7.00 | — | House Red, White & Pink Wine Happy hour menu |